
Seth MacFarlane arrives at the 61st Primetime Emmy Awards on Sunday, Sept. 20, 2009, in Los Angeles. (Matt Sayles/AP Photo)
Listen to the full piece:
Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.
HOST: Finding the right host for the Oscars ceremony has been a challenge in recent years. This year, Seth Macfarlane gets his shot. And while some people aren’t applauding the choice, comics everywhere will be rooting. No matter what happens.
Tony Maglio reports. (0:18)
NARR: Comedian and big-band crooner Seth Macfarlane is either the perfect choice for Oscar host, or a dangerous one.
MacFarlane looks like the boy next door, but his biting satire on “Family Guy” is the material of a much darker mind. His humor has offended a number of celebrities and critics. It’s also made him one of the most popular and panned people in Hollywood.
Recently, MacFarlane got in trouble from jokes he made on the Oscars nomination show. After naming the best supporting actress nominees, MacFarlane said this:
(0:28)
MACFARLANE: “Congratulations, you five ladies no longer have to pretend to be attracted to Harvey Weinstein” (0:05)
NARR: But that shot at the super-producer is tame by Macfarlane’s standards. What people truly worry about from the director of “Ted,” are jokes like this one: (0:08)
MACFARLANE: “I read Amour was co-produced in Austria and Germany, right? The last time Austria and Germany got together and co-produced something it was Hitler – but this is much better (much better, highly recommended, so much better).” (0:15)
Some people didn’t find that funny. In response to his critics, Macfarlane tweeted: “Lotta flap over that Adolf joke. Look, Amour was a great film, so how about this: Austria, we’ll give you the Oscar if you take back Arnold.” (0:15)
Ray Ellin is a comedian and host of the web-based talk show, “LateNet.” He believes that some of the criticism of Macfarlane’s jokes is a little overblown. (0:09)
ELLIN: “When you say the word Hitler, people get on edge. You say the word Jesus, a lot of people get on edge. And I get it; those are sort of red flags for people. But you know, the joke itself wasn’t that harsh just in its content.” (0:16)
NARR: After all, even that joke doesn’t compare to those Macfarlane tells in another venue where he’s made a name for himself. Here’s Macfarlane reading a future obituary he prepared for the Comedy Central Roast of Charlie Sheen. (0:12)
MACFARLANE: “’Charlie Sheen, who became a tabloid fixture due to his problems with drugs and alcohol, was found dead in his apartment.’ You know what, I actually just kind of copied Amy Winehouse’s obituary. I only had to change three things: the sex of the deceased, the location of the body and the part that says ‘a talent that will be missed.’ (0:21)
ELLIN: “On Comedy Central when they do roasts, they just go for the jugular. It’s the harshest thing you can say about somebody. But there’s a way of making fun of somebody or making funny of a movie without
being that sinister.” (0:10)
NARR: Ellin and comics around the country are eagerly waiting to see which route MacFarlane will choose on Sunday. It will be then when we see how this animated host handles his highly anticipated real life role.
Tony Maglio, Columbia Radio News. (0:14)